Senators Rรณnรกn Mullen's and Michael McDowell's full contributions to the Seanad debate on the Criminal Justice (Incitement to Violence or Hatred and Hate Offences) Bill today. The debate resumes tomorrow morning with Senator Sharon Keogan's contribution.
๐49
This media is not supported in your browser
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
You can hear Helen McEntee misrepresenting the nature of the hate legislation after accusing others of doing so in this clip:
"The core purpose of delivering this legislation is to ensure that vulnerable and minority communities can feel safe. That is the core aim of what we are setting out to achieve here. Nobody deserves to be targeted for the intrinsic and unchangeable characteristics of their identity."
One of the protected characteristics outlined in the bill is a person's religion. Someone's religion is not an intrinsic and unchangeable characteristic. A person can change their religion just like they can change their politics. Both are ideologies.
It's an important point because the legislation means assaults on a person or group due to their political ideology will be regarded less seriously in the eyes of the law than if they had been carried out on a person or group due to their religious ideology.
This means the legislation is discriminatory in favour of people who hold religious views.
"The core purpose of delivering this legislation is to ensure that vulnerable and minority communities can feel safe. That is the core aim of what we are setting out to achieve here. Nobody deserves to be targeted for the intrinsic and unchangeable characteristics of their identity."
One of the protected characteristics outlined in the bill is a person's religion. Someone's religion is not an intrinsic and unchangeable characteristic. A person can change their religion just like they can change their politics. Both are ideologies.
It's an important point because the legislation means assaults on a person or group due to their political ideology will be regarded less seriously in the eyes of the law than if they had been carried out on a person or group due to their religious ideology.
This means the legislation is discriminatory in favour of people who hold religious views.
๐คก40๐ค7๐4โค1
This media is not supported in your browser
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
Minister Helen McEntee says that her hate speech legislation doesn't seek to infringe on your rights to say offensive things.
Save this clip.
Save this clip.
๐34๐ค10โค1
This media is not supported in your browser
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
Here are the promises McEntee makes about her hate speech legislation.
๐น The bill will not criminalise somebody offending another person. Nobody will have a right not to be offended
๐น The rights to freedom of expression and freedom of speech will be maintained and she will defend them. They will be protected by Bunreacht na hรireann and the European convention of human rights.
๐น You will have a right to express your convictions and your opinions no matter how unpopular they might be.
๐น You will have a right to be divisive.
๐น You will have a right to be argumentative.
๐น You will have a right to offend others and to hold political opinions which are not the mainstream.
๐น She promises section 11 of the bill explicitly provides protection for freedom of expression and that discussion or criticism of matters relating to a protected characteristic will not constitute incitement to hatred in and of itself.
Keep her promises in mind while watching the next clip.
๐น The bill will not criminalise somebody offending another person. Nobody will have a right not to be offended
๐น The rights to freedom of expression and freedom of speech will be maintained and she will defend them. They will be protected by Bunreacht na hรireann and the European convention of human rights.
๐น You will have a right to express your convictions and your opinions no matter how unpopular they might be.
๐น You will have a right to be divisive.
๐น You will have a right to be argumentative.
๐น You will have a right to offend others and to hold political opinions which are not the mainstream.
๐น She promises section 11 of the bill explicitly provides protection for freedom of expression and that discussion or criticism of matters relating to a protected characteristic will not constitute incitement to hatred in and of itself.
Keep her promises in mind while watching the next clip.
โค13๐4
This media is not supported in your browser
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
Listen to the example she gives of material which would breach the hate speech legislation: A person travelling to a far-right rally with posters or leaflets. She says a lot this sort of material is now online too.
One action McEntee didn't take in all her promotion of the legislation was give us one example of a poster or leaflet deemed by her to be 'far-right' which should hopes her legislation will successfully criminalise. Where is it?
One action McEntee didn't take in all her promotion of the legislation was give us one example of a poster or leaflet deemed by her to be 'far-right' which should hopes her legislation will successfully criminalise. Where is it?
๐คฌ37๐19๐2๐ญ1
One (probably) last point I want to make on the hate speech legislation is that McEntee told the Seanad today that our rights to freedom of expression and freedom of speech will still be protected by Bunreacht na hรireann and the European Convention of Human Rights.
In 2009, an Austrian woman who grew up in Iran and then worked in embassies in Kuwait and Libya took part in a public conference on Islam where she compared the marriage of Mohammed to a 6-year-old Aisha to paedophilia, stating: โWhat do we call it, if it is not paedophilia?โ
As a result, she was convicted in 2011 by Austrian courts for โdisparaging religious doctrinesโ, an offense under Article 188 of the Austrian Criminal Code. The woman then complained to the European Court of Human Rights alleging a violation of her freedom of expression.
In 2018, the ECHR issued their judgment and considered that the remarks in question were โlikely to arouse justified indignation in Muslimsโ and constituted โa malicious violation of the spirit of tolerance, which was one of the bases of a democratic society . . . and putting religious peace at risk.โ
It concluded that the condemnation of the woman was justified under the European Convention on Human Rights.
Islamic authorities in Muslim countries considered that this ECHR judgment proved them right in their policy repressing blasphemy.
There's your protection.
๐ eclj.org
In 2009, an Austrian woman who grew up in Iran and then worked in embassies in Kuwait and Libya took part in a public conference on Islam where she compared the marriage of Mohammed to a 6-year-old Aisha to paedophilia, stating: โWhat do we call it, if it is not paedophilia?โ
As a result, she was convicted in 2011 by Austrian courts for โdisparaging religious doctrinesโ, an offense under Article 188 of the Austrian Criminal Code. The woman then complained to the European Court of Human Rights alleging a violation of her freedom of expression.
In 2018, the ECHR issued their judgment and considered that the remarks in question were โlikely to arouse justified indignation in Muslimsโ and constituted โa malicious violation of the spirit of tolerance, which was one of the bases of a democratic society . . . and putting religious peace at risk.โ
It concluded that the condemnation of the woman was justified under the European Convention on Human Rights.
Islamic authorities in Muslim countries considered that this ECHR judgment proved them right in their policy repressing blasphemy.
There's your protection.
๐ eclj.org
European Centre for Law and Justice
[Op-Ed Article] In Defense of Freedom of Expression in Religious Matters
Collective opinion column published in the French Journal Valeurs Actuelles on March 15, 2019. As authors and researchers dealing with religious issues,
๐36โค5
This media is not supported in your browser
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
The full contribution from Fianna Fรกil Senator Denis O'Donovan in the Seanad debate yesterday on Helen McEntee's Hate Offences Bill.
O'Donovan said he has concerns that the bill conflicts with Bunreacht na hรireann and that it could be successfully challenged in the Supreme Court or the European Court of Human Rights which would lead to embarrassment. He said the matter deserved a referendum to change the constitution if that was the will of the public.
"The conflict with the Irish constitution is so strong in this instance that I think it warrants (and maybe this is a far-reaching view) that should we consider having a referendum on changing our constitution pre legislation. I think maybe the people of this country should have a view and have a vote as to where we're going in this regard."
He added that in his 30 year career his views had only deviated from that of his party on three occasions but he would have great reluctance putting his name to the legislation.
O'Donovan said he has concerns that the bill conflicts with Bunreacht na hรireann and that it could be successfully challenged in the Supreme Court or the European Court of Human Rights which would lead to embarrassment. He said the matter deserved a referendum to change the constitution if that was the will of the public.
"The conflict with the Irish constitution is so strong in this instance that I think it warrants (and maybe this is a far-reaching view) that should we consider having a referendum on changing our constitution pre legislation. I think maybe the people of this country should have a view and have a vote as to where we're going in this regard."
He added that in his 30 year career his views had only deviated from that of his party on three occasions but he would have great reluctance putting his name to the legislation.
๐56๐3โค2๐2
Five Slovakians have appeared in court charged in connection with the investigation into the murder of Ashling Murphy.
Marek Puska, 34, Lubomir Puska, 35, and Lucia Istokova, 34, were charged with withholding information on dates between 12 January 2022 and 27 January 2022.
Two others, Jozefina Grundzova, 33, and Viera Gaziova, 38, were charged with impeding the arrest of an alleged offender on dates between 12 and 14 January 2022.
They were all provided an interpreter and remanded on bail.
The trial of the Slovakian man accused of Ms Murphy's murder, 32-year-old Jozef Puska, is due to take place later this year.
๐ rte.ie
Marek Puska, 34, Lubomir Puska, 35, and Lucia Istokova, 34, were charged with withholding information on dates between 12 January 2022 and 27 January 2022.
Two others, Jozefina Grundzova, 33, and Viera Gaziova, 38, were charged with impeding the arrest of an alleged offender on dates between 12 and 14 January 2022.
They were all provided an interpreter and remanded on bail.
The trial of the Slovakian man accused of Ms Murphy's murder, 32-year-old Jozef Puska, is due to take place later this year.
๐ rte.ie
๐37๐คฎ17๐คฌ5โค3
This media is not supported in your browser
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
Three foreign men who just came to Ireland looking for a better life have been arrested for robbing houses in Bluebell, Dublin.
#NewToTheParish
๐ twitter.com
#NewToTheParish
๐ twitter.com
๐66๐คฌ19๐9๐3๐1
New invasive species just dropped.
Oak Processionary Moth nests were found on four Oak trees in a Dublin housing estate.
The backs of older caterpillars are covered with up to 63,000 pointed defensive bristles containing an urticating toxin which can become airborne readily and can cause rashing, pruritus, conjunctivitis and, if inhaled, pharyngitis and respiratory distress, including asthma or even anaphylaxis.
They can strip trees bare, leaving them weakened and vulnerable to other threats.
In southern Europe their populations are controlled by natural predators who are not present in northern Europe.
It's believed they came in on imports of oak plants from England where they were accidentally introduced in 2005.
If you see any call 01-5058885
๐ archive.is
Oak Processionary Moth nests were found on four Oak trees in a Dublin housing estate.
The backs of older caterpillars are covered with up to 63,000 pointed defensive bristles containing an urticating toxin which can become airborne readily and can cause rashing, pruritus, conjunctivitis and, if inhaled, pharyngitis and respiratory distress, including asthma or even anaphylaxis.
They can strip trees bare, leaving them weakened and vulnerable to other threats.
In southern Europe their populations are controlled by natural predators who are not present in northern Europe.
It's believed they came in on imports of oak plants from England where they were accidentally introduced in 2005.
If you see any call 01-5058885
๐ archive.is
๐23๐ฅ9๐คฎ6โค3๐คจ3๐2
Cork Pride sponsors pull out due to "the backdrop of corporate lay-offs and turbulent economic headwinds" and no other reason. ๐
๐ irishexaminer
๐ irishexaminer
โค48๐18๐8๐3๐คฉ2๐1
This media is not supported in your browser
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
๐จ Child abduction attempt in the Louth/Meath area
Virgin Media News has learned that there was a child abduction attempt made last month when a man pretending to be from the HSE's Home Support Services called to a home and told a parent that he needed to collect their child for an 'out of home support provision'. When the man was unable to provide ID, he left.
The incident was reported to the Garda and Tusla. The HSE is advising parents to report any suspicious activity or calls.
VM News say they could not follow up on the investigation with the Garda as the HSE will not tell them the location of the attempted abduction, only that it occurred in the Louth/Meath area.
The matter came to light when some parents, who use the Home Support Services, received a letter warning them about the incident and then contacted Virgin Media news to query it.
The HSE has suffered two cyberattacks in the last three years in which over 100,000 people had their personal data stolen.
๐ twitter.com
Virgin Media News has learned that there was a child abduction attempt made last month when a man pretending to be from the HSE's Home Support Services called to a home and told a parent that he needed to collect their child for an 'out of home support provision'. When the man was unable to provide ID, he left.
The incident was reported to the Garda and Tusla. The HSE is advising parents to report any suspicious activity or calls.
VM News say they could not follow up on the investigation with the Garda as the HSE will not tell them the location of the attempted abduction, only that it occurred in the Louth/Meath area.
The matter came to light when some parents, who use the Home Support Services, received a letter warning them about the incident and then contacted Virgin Media news to query it.
The HSE has suffered two cyberattacks in the last three years in which over 100,000 people had their personal data stolen.
๐ twitter.com
๐คฏ26๐คฌ17๐3
A judge has refused to order the arrest of 53 asylum seekers which a communist organisation are using to occupy James Mac Sweeney House at 10 Berkeley Street in Phibsborough.
This, he said, was due to a lack of evidence before the court about the identities of the persons on the property.
He was not satisfied that all of those alleged to be in occupation have been made aware of the orders to vacate the premises previously made by the court.
Additional efforts must be made to ascertain the identities of those on the property, and that they be properly served with the proceedings before the orders sought could be granted, he said.
Gonna be tricky if they're undocumented...
The self-styled 'Revolutionary Housing League' began squatting at the property, which is being redeveloped by a charitable housing association to accommodate the elderly, on May 12th, the day their shanty town was cleared out by concerned locals on Sandwith Street.
๐ archive.is
This, he said, was due to a lack of evidence before the court about the identities of the persons on the property.
He was not satisfied that all of those alleged to be in occupation have been made aware of the orders to vacate the premises previously made by the court.
Additional efforts must be made to ascertain the identities of those on the property, and that they be properly served with the proceedings before the orders sought could be granted, he said.
Gonna be tricky if they're undocumented...
The self-styled 'Revolutionary Housing League' began squatting at the property, which is being redeveloped by a charitable housing association to accommodate the elderly, on May 12th, the day their shanty town was cleared out by concerned locals on Sandwith Street.
๐ archive.is
archive.is
Judge refuses to order arrest of asylum seekers occupying building eaโฆ
archived 14 Jun 2023 16:41:17 UTC
๐คฌ59๐6
Derry: A failed Sudanese asylum seeker with no passport but who is scheduled for deportation has been refused bail after being charged with sexually assaulting a vulnerable female crying on Derry's Walls on June 13.
๐ archive.ph | ๐ archive.ph
๐ archive.ph | ๐ archive.ph
๐คฌ61๐คฏ3
Media is too big
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
Finglas taxi driver Gavin Pepper's house raided at 6:30 this morning โ phone and jacket seized. Gardaรญ told him they had a warrant related to the shanty town being cleared out on Sandwith Street.
๐ twitter.com
๐ twitter.com
๐คฌ75๐ฅ26๐คก4๐3โค2๐2๐ฅด2
Forwarded from The State of Ireland
Residents out in Westside, Galway City this evening as 39 migrant men are on their way
๐ฅ74๐15๐10๐คก1