Relevant for Tribes unit in paper-II.
What is the issue?
Parliamentary Standing Committee on Public Undertakings report on NHPC published in early August, found several hydropower projects delayed due to the "100 per cent Gram Sabha consent" rule, and the report recommended reducing that 100 per cent consent to 70β75 per cent for large hydropower infrastructure projects of national importance.
Relevant thinkers
Antonio Gramsci: hegemony and manufactured consent
Virginius Xaxa: State development policy toward STs are producing structural marginalization even while claiming inclusion
What is the issue?
Parliamentary Standing Committee on Public Undertakings report on NHPC published in early August, found several hydropower projects delayed due to the "100 per cent Gram Sabha consent" rule, and the report recommended reducing that 100 per cent consent to 70β75 per cent for large hydropower infrastructure projects of national importance.
Relevant thinkers
Antonio Gramsci: hegemony and manufactured consent
Virginius Xaxa: State development policy toward STs are producing structural marginalization even while claiming inclusion
β€6π€―1
Relevant for religion unit in papers 1 & 2.
Swaminarayan Sampradaya is a "sect" of Hinduism whereas BAPS is a "sub-sect".
But from a sociological lens, BAPS can be seen as a "sect with cult characteristics" because it acts like a a breakaway religious splinter group that retains ties to an established parent religion while adopting extreme authoritarian control, total lifestyle demands, and absolute devotion to a charismatic leader. The charismatic leader here is "Sahajanand Swami"
Swaminarayan Sampradaya is a "sect" of Hinduism whereas BAPS is a "sub-sect".
But from a sociological lens, BAPS can be seen as a "sect with cult characteristics" because it acts like a a breakaway religious splinter group that retains ties to an established parent religion while adopting extreme authoritarian control, total lifestyle demands, and absolute devotion to a charismatic leader. The charismatic leader here is "Sahajanand Swami"
β€7
Catharine MacKinnon argued that the law's treatment of consent within marriage reflects male-dominated definitions of sexuality itself.
Kalpana Kannabiran says that the marital rape debate is one of a conflict between Constitutional morality vs. Public morality.
According to Hindu Marriage Act, marriage is considered as a "sacrament". Hence, notions of "purity" or "sacred and profane" can be applied in this context.
Relevant for family, marriage and kinship in paper-I and II
Kalpana Kannabiran says that the marital rape debate is one of a conflict between Constitutional morality vs. Public morality.
According to Hindu Marriage Act, marriage is considered as a "sacrament". Hence, notions of "purity" or "sacred and profane" can be applied in this context.
Relevant for family, marriage and kinship in paper-I and II
β€9
Forwarded from UPSCPrep.com
A lot of aspirants were asking us to bring Write Unlimited to optional subjects like Sociology and PSIR.
So, we heard you. And here it is.
Write Unlimited is a simple idea: you write as much as you want, and we evaluate it for you. You can practise questions of your choice, get detailed feedback, and keep improving with every answer.
Now, the same format is available for Sociology and PSIR as well.
You have just four months to seriously work on your optional answer writing. Make the most of this time and practise as much as you can.
These courses have limited seats. Once the seats are filled, admissions will close to ensure that we can maintain the quality of evaluation and feedback.
Enroll today: courses.upscprep.com/products
So, we heard you. And here it is.
Write Unlimited is a simple idea: you write as much as you want, and we evaluate it for you. You can practise questions of your choice, get detailed feedback, and keep improving with every answer.
Now, the same format is available for Sociology and PSIR as well.
You have just four months to seriously work on your optional answer writing. Make the most of this time and practise as much as you can.
These courses have limited seats. Once the seats are filled, admissions will close to ensure that we can maintain the quality of evaluation and feedback.
Enroll today: courses.upscprep.com/products
β€6
Note the definitions of "Sattvik, Rajas, Tamas" here. It is relevant for "Indology" in paper-II
Indology or book view looks at Manu Smriti and other scriptures to understand Indian society. According to Manu Smriti, Brahmins have more of "Sattva" characteristics, Kshatriyas have "Rajas" characteristics and Shudras have "Tamas" characteristics. These are casteist notions that need to be challenged.
Indology or book view looks at Manu Smriti and other scriptures to understand Indian society. According to Manu Smriti, Brahmins have more of "Sattva" characteristics, Kshatriyas have "Rajas" characteristics and Shudras have "Tamas" characteristics. These are casteist notions that need to be challenged.
β€13π1
Sociological theories that can be applied here:
1. Dominant class ideology by Marx: The dominant powers in the society, that is the rich and powerful want to control how much of their privilege is visible.
2. Power elite theory by C.W.Mills: The power elites who have class, caste and political privilege protect their resources
3. Andre Beteille's three-dimensional framework of social stratification: caste, class and power
4. Dominant caste by M.N. Srinivas: This is evidenced by dominant caste groups like Lingayats and Vokkaligas(Karnataka) petitioning against the caste census
1. Dominant class ideology by Marx: The dominant powers in the society, that is the rich and powerful want to control how much of their privilege is visible.
2. Power elite theory by C.W.Mills: The power elites who have class, caste and political privilege protect their resources
3. Andre Beteille's three-dimensional framework of social stratification: caste, class and power
4. Dominant caste by M.N. Srinivas: This is evidenced by dominant caste groups like Lingayats and Vokkaligas(Karnataka) petitioning against the caste census
β€14
Citizenship is very very important for "Politics and Society"
T.H. Marshall says that citizenship is a βstatus bestowed on all those who are full members of a community.β
Citizenship gives one the right to vote.
Supreme Court says that the Election Commission cannot determine who is a citizen. Only the Ministry of Home Affairs can decide that. Using Aadhar to enumerate the voter list is a viable solution because it is cost-effective and not a lot of people will be left behind like in SIR
T.H. Marshall says that citizenship is a βstatus bestowed on all those who are full members of a community.β
Citizenship gives one the right to vote.
Supreme Court says that the Election Commission cannot determine who is a citizen. Only the Ministry of Home Affairs can decide that. Using Aadhar to enumerate the voter list is a viable solution because it is cost-effective and not a lot of people will be left behind like in SIR
π12
Important for changing facets of marriage.
What recognitions are available for same-sex couples/non-heterosexual couples?
1. Same-sex partner can take medical call for the other
2. They can open joint accounts
What recognitions are NOT available for same-sex couples?
1. They are not considered as "spouse" under any of the Indian marriage laws
2. They cannot be treated as spouses for the purposes of Income Tax Act. When heterosexual couples exchange gifts, they are tax exempt
What recognitions are available for same-sex couples/non-heterosexual couples?
1. Same-sex partner can take medical call for the other
2. They can open joint accounts
What recognitions are NOT available for same-sex couples?
1. They are not considered as "spouse" under any of the Indian marriage laws
2. They cannot be treated as spouses for the purposes of Income Tax Act. When heterosexual couples exchange gifts, they are tax exempt
β€8
Very very important article on family and declining TFR.
Two thinkers are mentioned here:
1. Linda Gordon β We cannot talk about women empowerment without addressing how time is organized for everybody else. For example, women take a larger share of household chores. An extended maternity leave without talking about paternity leave squarely puts the responsibility on the mother alone
2. Betty Friedan β Motherhood is sold as "fulfillment" while it is actually a huge responsibility
Author advocates for a paternity leave policy while acknowledging the fact that child-rearing is not the woman's job alone.
Women as primary caregivers was advocated by Parsons. Thinkers of critical school are of the opinion that family is the greatest oppressor.
Two thinkers are mentioned here:
1. Linda Gordon β We cannot talk about women empowerment without addressing how time is organized for everybody else. For example, women take a larger share of household chores. An extended maternity leave without talking about paternity leave squarely puts the responsibility on the mother alone
2. Betty Friedan β Motherhood is sold as "fulfillment" while it is actually a huge responsibility
Author advocates for a paternity leave policy while acknowledging the fact that child-rearing is not the woman's job alone.
Women as primary caregivers was advocated by Parsons. Thinkers of critical school are of the opinion that family is the greatest oppressor.
β€18π5
Very very important article for paper-2 under the following topics:
1. Religious Communities in India
2. Family, marriage and kinship
3. Constitution, Law and Social Change
Sociological perspectives:
T.N. Madan = Personal laws are not just laws. They correspond to cultural identity. Hence, UCC will undermine diversity
Zoya Hassan = UCC debate only relatively recently has taken up "gender equality" cause, otherwise it was more about secularism vs religious law
Upendra Baxi = UCC is nothing but legal centralism vs. legal pluralism
1. Religious Communities in India
2. Family, marriage and kinship
3. Constitution, Law and Social Change
Sociological perspectives:
T.N. Madan = Personal laws are not just laws. They correspond to cultural identity. Hence, UCC will undermine diversity
Zoya Hassan = UCC debate only relatively recently has taken up "gender equality" cause, otherwise it was more about secularism vs religious law
Upendra Baxi = UCC is nothing but legal centralism vs. legal pluralism
π8β€3