Some persons may argue that the INEC’s guideline which provides for the uploading of result sheets with BIVAS and the viewing of Election result on IRev was made by INEC pursuant to the provisions of the Electoral Act; thereby constituting a bye-law which must be obeyed. This line of argument finds solace in the case of PDP V. INEC & ORS (2015) LPELR-25669 Pp. 69-70, paras. D-A, where the Court of Appeal held per AGIM, J.C.A. that:
"I agree with the submission of Learned counsel for the appellant that the Approved Guidelines for the Regulation of the Conduct of the 2015 General Elections having been made by the 1st respondent pursuant to the power vested on it by S.153 of the Electoral Act 2010 as amended to subject to the provisions of the Act, issue regulations, guidelines, or manuals for the purpose of giving effect to the provisions of this Act and for its administration thereof, is part of the Electoral Act. Therefore non-compliance with the provisions of the Guidelines qualifies as non-compliance with the Act."
May I however quickly draw our attention to the following provisions of the Electoral Act:
Section 134(2) -
“An act or omission which may be contrary to an instruction or directive of the Commission or of an officer appointed for the purpose of the election but which is not contrary to the provisions of this Act shall not of itself be a ground for questioning the election.”
Section 135(1) -
“An election shall not be liable to be invalidated by reason of non-compliance with the provisions of this Act if it appears to the Election Tribunal or Court that the election was conducted substantially in accordance with the principles of this Act and that the non-compliance did not affect substantially the result of the election.”
A visit to the IReV portal will reveal that most results were uploaded after the election and not real-time. Let us even assume for the sake of argument that no result was uploaded on the IReV. Can this inaction invalidate the election, especially where the results contained in the copies of the polling unit results given to political party agents tally with the final result declared? The yardstick that has been engaged by courts on this issue is to determine whether the non-compliance has substantially affected the result of the election.
Is the IReV portal the only means to ascertain votes scored by the political parties? If the answer is in the affirmative, then the failure to upload polling unit results on the portal would be irreparably fatal to the whole election as the non-compliance could be said to have substantially affected the election. This is because there would be no alternative means to ascertain polling units result. In advancing an argument predicated on such fact, the decision in the case of UZU & ANOR V. OGBU & ORS (2012) LPELR-9775 P. 132, para. A, can be relied on. In that case, it was held that:
"I agree also with learned counsel for the Appellants and on the authorities of Nweke v. Ejims (supra); Ajadi v. Ajibola (2004) 16 NWLR (pt 898) 91 at182; Ogboru v. Uduaghan (supra) at 706; Terab v. Lawan (1999) 3 NWLR (pt. 231) 5 569 at 569; Section 49(1) and 2 and Chapters 3 and 4 of the Manual for Election Officials that where there is no accreditation and no voting, the results of the election cannot be sustained. Also, the marking of the voters register in the 2011 election as provided by the Manual is the only ascertainable method of proving that accreditation and voting took place.”
In this election, the IReV portal is not the only means to ascertain valid votes scored by the political parties. The polling unit result sheets (with copies given to the various political party agents) which formed the basis of results declared remain the ascertainable method of proving votes scored. Undoubtedly, the accessibility of polling unit level results through IReV increases transparency and public trust in our electoral process.
"I agree with the submission of Learned counsel for the appellant that the Approved Guidelines for the Regulation of the Conduct of the 2015 General Elections having been made by the 1st respondent pursuant to the power vested on it by S.153 of the Electoral Act 2010 as amended to subject to the provisions of the Act, issue regulations, guidelines, or manuals for the purpose of giving effect to the provisions of this Act and for its administration thereof, is part of the Electoral Act. Therefore non-compliance with the provisions of the Guidelines qualifies as non-compliance with the Act."
May I however quickly draw our attention to the following provisions of the Electoral Act:
Section 134(2) -
“An act or omission which may be contrary to an instruction or directive of the Commission or of an officer appointed for the purpose of the election but which is not contrary to the provisions of this Act shall not of itself be a ground for questioning the election.”
Section 135(1) -
“An election shall not be liable to be invalidated by reason of non-compliance with the provisions of this Act if it appears to the Election Tribunal or Court that the election was conducted substantially in accordance with the principles of this Act and that the non-compliance did not affect substantially the result of the election.”
A visit to the IReV portal will reveal that most results were uploaded after the election and not real-time. Let us even assume for the sake of argument that no result was uploaded on the IReV. Can this inaction invalidate the election, especially where the results contained in the copies of the polling unit results given to political party agents tally with the final result declared? The yardstick that has been engaged by courts on this issue is to determine whether the non-compliance has substantially affected the result of the election.
Is the IReV portal the only means to ascertain votes scored by the political parties? If the answer is in the affirmative, then the failure to upload polling unit results on the portal would be irreparably fatal to the whole election as the non-compliance could be said to have substantially affected the election. This is because there would be no alternative means to ascertain polling units result. In advancing an argument predicated on such fact, the decision in the case of UZU & ANOR V. OGBU & ORS (2012) LPELR-9775 P. 132, para. A, can be relied on. In that case, it was held that:
"I agree also with learned counsel for the Appellants and on the authorities of Nweke v. Ejims (supra); Ajadi v. Ajibola (2004) 16 NWLR (pt 898) 91 at182; Ogboru v. Uduaghan (supra) at 706; Terab v. Lawan (1999) 3 NWLR (pt. 231) 5 569 at 569; Section 49(1) and 2 and Chapters 3 and 4 of the Manual for Election Officials that where there is no accreditation and no voting, the results of the election cannot be sustained. Also, the marking of the voters register in the 2011 election as provided by the Manual is the only ascertainable method of proving that accreditation and voting took place.”
In this election, the IReV portal is not the only means to ascertain valid votes scored by the political parties. The polling unit result sheets (with copies given to the various political party agents) which formed the basis of results declared remain the ascertainable method of proving votes scored. Undoubtedly, the accessibility of polling unit level results through IReV increases transparency and public trust in our electoral process.
Driving home this conversation, the electorates need to know that as the electoral contestation moves from the polling units to the Tribunals, the rules of engagement has to be strictly followed for any petition to come out of the Tribunal alive! Some facts that may appear seemingly strong enough to upturn an election may not find where to stand in the Electoral Act.
Election petition cases are of interest to the general populace, and as such, undue technicalities should not be allowed to erode substantial justice. This point was echoed in the case TAFIDA V. TAFIDA V. BAFARAWA & ORS (1999) LPELR-6510 P. 19, paras. B-D, where it was held that:
"...The attitude of the Court in such special proceedings i.e. election petition, is liberal as it is always better to consider the petition on its merit rather than technicalities. See: Obi v. Mbakwe (1984) 1 SCNLR 192: Ogunbiyi v. Ogundipe (1992) 9 NWLR (Pt.263) 24; Opia v. Ibru (1992) 3 NWLR (Pt.231) 658."
Any request to nullify the result of the just concluded election on the ground that results were not uploaded on the IReV portal would be riding on the rough back of technicalities. The Election Petition Tribunals would not hesitate to decline any such invitation to embark on a rudderless voyage.
Petitioners and Electorates should therefore be guided on their expectations.
Otunba Olumide Olaiya
11:03:2023
Election petition cases are of interest to the general populace, and as such, undue technicalities should not be allowed to erode substantial justice. This point was echoed in the case TAFIDA V. TAFIDA V. BAFARAWA & ORS (1999) LPELR-6510 P. 19, paras. B-D, where it was held that:
"...The attitude of the Court in such special proceedings i.e. election petition, is liberal as it is always better to consider the petition on its merit rather than technicalities. See: Obi v. Mbakwe (1984) 1 SCNLR 192: Ogunbiyi v. Ogundipe (1992) 9 NWLR (Pt.263) 24; Opia v. Ibru (1992) 3 NWLR (Pt.231) 658."
Any request to nullify the result of the just concluded election on the ground that results were not uploaded on the IReV portal would be riding on the rough back of technicalities. The Election Petition Tribunals would not hesitate to decline any such invitation to embark on a rudderless voyage.
Petitioners and Electorates should therefore be guided on their expectations.
Otunba Olumide Olaiya
11:03:2023
👍2
This media is not supported in your browser
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
Drama as a Naval Officer Beats Up PoliceStation Guard 😊
🚷 This page doesn't support violence
🚷 This page doesn't support violence
😁6❤1
BREAKING NEWS
INEC Declears Dapo Abiodun Of The All Progressives Congress APC, Winner, 2023 Ogun Governorship Election
#ogunupdate
INEC Declears Dapo Abiodun Of The All Progressives Congress APC, Winner, 2023 Ogun Governorship Election
#ogunupdate
❤4👍2👏1
This media is not supported in your browser
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
JUST IN
One dead in Panseke, Abeokuta in what looks like a cult clashe
People are scampering for safety as at the time of this report.
Stay safe if you area in that area or you have to pass through the area
#ogunupdate
One dead in Panseke, Abeokuta in what looks like a cult clashe
People are scampering for safety as at the time of this report.
Stay safe if you area in that area or you have to pass through the area
#ogunupdate
This media is not supported in your browser
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
*This ugly Incident was reported today 30th of March 2023. If you know the family or relative of the man, kindly inform them. Bad and sad News everywhere in Nigeria 🇳🇬*
😢7👍1
This media is not supported in your browser
VIEW IN TELEGRAM
This is Inhuman and wickedness. O God, how can this little child get justice. Let us keep sharing until it got attention. It is inhuman.
😢7❤1👎1
Dear Lord,
As we embark on the journey of the new month of April, we ask for Your guidance, protection, and blessings. May this month bring us joy, happiness, and success in all our endeavors.
#ogunupdate
As we embark on the journey of the new month of April, we ask for Your guidance, protection, and blessings. May this month bring us joy, happiness, and success in all our endeavors.
#ogunupdate
❤2
Title: FATAL RTA/RTC at sapaade, on ibadan- lagos expressway (inbound Lagos)
1: Date: 05-04-2023
2: Time of RTA/RTC: 0640hrs
3: Time of arrival: 0654hrs
4: Route: Saapade
5: LGA : Remo north
6: Vehicles involved stated below
1.mazda bus with reg num FFA 553 YR
2. Unknow truck
7: Rescue Team: TRACE, PAPA OSCAR
8: Cause of RTA, dangerous driving coupled with over speeding on the part of the mazda bus, which resulted in hitting the the moving truck from the rear according to an eyeswithness.
9: No of occupatant: 2 (1 male and 1 female )
10: No of injured: nill
11: No of death: 1 female
12: Action taken. The presumed dead was taken to FOS ipara by the owner of the morgue thru his ambulance, while tow truck was contacted to remove the accidented bus from the road to papa Oscar's cage ode remo.
1: Date: 05-04-2023
2: Time of RTA/RTC: 0640hrs
3: Time of arrival: 0654hrs
4: Route: Saapade
5: LGA : Remo north
6: Vehicles involved stated below
1.mazda bus with reg num FFA 553 YR
2. Unknow truck
7: Rescue Team: TRACE, PAPA OSCAR
8: Cause of RTA, dangerous driving coupled with over speeding on the part of the mazda bus, which resulted in hitting the the moving truck from the rear according to an eyeswithness.
9: No of occupatant: 2 (1 male and 1 female )
10: No of injured: nill
11: No of death: 1 female
12: Action taken. The presumed dead was taken to FOS ipara by the owner of the morgue thru his ambulance, while tow truck was contacted to remove the accidented bus from the road to papa Oscar's cage ode remo.
👍1😢1