The New Order: Last Days of Europe
1.16K subscribers
9.44K photos
279 videos
1 file
6.46K links
The New Order: Last Days of Europe is an ambitious mod for Hearts of Iron IV presenting a unique alternate history Cold War between Germany, Japan and the USA, starting in 1962. Will you save the world or help destroy it?
@reddit2telegram
Download Telegram
I made the Ashes Of Libertad Map in TNO
https://redd.it/16zjynn
@tnomod
A limited critique of the portrayal of Kissinger's foreign policy in TNO

You know for the guy that was famous for realpolitik, its kinda strange he cant do any in TNO.

# 1. Japanese Detente doesn't make sense most of the time

I honestly cant see this being anything but an OTL reference. Kissinger's detente with china had a few primary motivations, most if not none of which exist in most games of TNO.

1. Encouraging the Sino-Soviet split. By 1962 not only has there been a German-Japanese split, there's an entire 3 way cold war.
2. Negotiations with the soviets. Detente gave America a stronger BATNA when negotiating with the soviets. But Kissinger refuses to negotiate with Germany, again making this point void.
3. China was currently a third world country (in the modern developmental sense), but Kissinger recognized they were a great power in a very rough spot, and would have the upper hand negotiating while they were still weak. TNOTL japan is tied as one of the superpowers.
4. Excluding China from the international system would lead China move aggressively assert itself, which could be avoided by just recognizing them as a great power.
1. Japan is already recognized as a superpower
2. There's not really an international system to invite Japan into

Both a stronger BATNA with Germany and rebuilding an international system would make sense in most games of TNO if Kissinger chooses to work with Germany along with Japan. There's also a few situations where purely Japanese-American Detente makes sense, ex: an extremely aggressive Germany and a relatively weak Japan and America. It all depends on the situation which Kissinger should respond to with different strategies, y'know, the definition of realpolitik.

# 2. Kissinger's primary focus should be on the Americas

Honestly, every president's primary focus should be on the Americas, especially since Italy will soon be unable to join the OFN. As for Kissinger himself, we can look to his writings on what to do about South America.

"Emphasizing reciprocal obligations and cooperative action, the ultimate and dramatic goal is the creation of a free-trade area from Alaska to Cape Horn — a concept that, a short time ago, would have been considered hopelessly utopian.

A Western Hemisphere-wide free-trade system — with NAFTA as the initial step — would give the Americas a commanding role no matter what happens." -Diplomacy Pg 832

While the situation that lead Kissinger to write this was greatly different than TNOTL, the broad strokes of America facing increasingly multi polar competition from Asia and Europe is surprisingly similar. South America also is, compared to the rest of the world, ideologically Aligned with America in 62.

# 3. Going for Hawaii is stupid, and other thoughts

In 1940 Japanese people made up a plurality of Hawaii's population, with only 100k or so white people, who almost certainly fled when Japan acquired Hawaii. By 62 Hawaii has been Japanese for nearly two decades, inhabited by almost only Japanese people, and an extremely important strategic location for Japan. The US is not getting Hawaii back, nor would it really want to, especially considering how extra racist the US would likely be to Japanese people, why would they want a state full of them. Kissinger should break with the other presidents foreign policy and not seek Hawaii. The US would not net gain from any deal that japan would realistically propose for the Island, if Japan would propose one at all. At the very most America should be able to ask for a neutral Hawaii.

There's a ton of other issues with TNO America's foreign policy, but its beyond the scope of what I wanted to write right now. Kirkpatrick similarly makes no sense compared to her real life foreign policy. America is far too afraid to straight up invade places with its full military, and the CIA is extremely underused. Diplomacy in TNO is generally nonexistent.

Finally, before anyone makes this point, Kissinger would not compromise