The issue of the South African war
The South African civil war is one of the oldest elements of TNO, having been used in the original demo. However, it's never quite made a whole lot of sense. First, it's not quite clear why the United Party managed to hold onto power in this timeline when they lost the 1948 election IRL and their support dwindled after that. The second problem is how the civil war happens; either the United Party adopts policies from the IRL end of apartheid in the 90s while are rather out of character for the UP (and the circumstances mean that the reason for those changes doesn't exist), or there is a Boer revolt for basically no reason (if the Afrikaners hated the UP that much, it wouldn't be in power considering they dominate the electorate).
So, a possible way to rework this while keeping the civil war would be to change the starting situation so that South Africa starts controlled by the National Party (or possibly a UP-NP 'national unity coalition') with a somewhat pro-German alignment. However, a large portion of the military have strongly anti-German sentiments, and when the German succession crisis occurs a group of officers with American backing launch a coup. The coup takes over the parliament in Cape Town but fails to take the cabinet in Pretoria and hence the country is plunged into civil war between the German-backed government and American-backed military rebels, with a Japanese-backed ANC revolt thrown in for good measure. This would also more conveniently explain why the war might be considered controversial in the US, as the US would be openly supporting a military coup against a 'legitimately elected' (for a given value of democratic) government.
https://redd.it/18857y8
@tnomod
The South African civil war is one of the oldest elements of TNO, having been used in the original demo. However, it's never quite made a whole lot of sense. First, it's not quite clear why the United Party managed to hold onto power in this timeline when they lost the 1948 election IRL and their support dwindled after that. The second problem is how the civil war happens; either the United Party adopts policies from the IRL end of apartheid in the 90s while are rather out of character for the UP (and the circumstances mean that the reason for those changes doesn't exist), or there is a Boer revolt for basically no reason (if the Afrikaners hated the UP that much, it wouldn't be in power considering they dominate the electorate).
So, a possible way to rework this while keeping the civil war would be to change the starting situation so that South Africa starts controlled by the National Party (or possibly a UP-NP 'national unity coalition') with a somewhat pro-German alignment. However, a large portion of the military have strongly anti-German sentiments, and when the German succession crisis occurs a group of officers with American backing launch a coup. The coup takes over the parliament in Cape Town but fails to take the cabinet in Pretoria and hence the country is plunged into civil war between the German-backed government and American-backed military rebels, with a Japanese-backed ANC revolt thrown in for good measure. This would also more conveniently explain why the war might be considered controversial in the US, as the US would be openly supporting a military coup against a 'legitimately elected' (for a given value of democratic) government.
https://redd.it/18857y8
@tnomod
Wikipedia
1948 South African general election
General elections were held in South Africa on 26 May 1948. They represented a turning point in the country's history, as despite receiving just under half of the votes cast, the United Party and its leader, incumbent Prime Minister Jan Smuts, were ousted…
THEY REMOVED JELLYCOE!!
so, I come back to TNO after like half a year of not playing it, I open it, I see some 'United Kingdom????' like ,seriously, having to go to war as england for once is cool!!! and, worst of all, they're under actual fascists instead of a bunch of people pretending to be fascists to avoid germany invading on them again, and also, what the hell is this 'British Fascism?????" but the worst has yet to come, I set the custom country path thing to make it so that HMMLR win, and it turns out they don't have jellicoeas a election option! now I can't get my based 10 percent GDP growth at the peak of the oil crisis! or my restoration of the pre-war order in full! worst of all, I can't build my big bad battleship fleet to destroy kriegsmarine! GIVE ME MY JELLYCOE BACK! give me my DAVID STERLING MSA SOLDIERS OF THE QUEEN BACK!!!
​
https://redd.it/18cz1ve
@tnomod
so, I come back to TNO after like half a year of not playing it, I open it, I see some 'United Kingdom????' like ,seriously, having to go to war as england for once is cool!!! and, worst of all, they're under actual fascists instead of a bunch of people pretending to be fascists to avoid germany invading on them again, and also, what the hell is this 'British Fascism?????" but the worst has yet to come, I set the custom country path thing to make it so that HMMLR win, and it turns out they don't have jellicoeas a election option! now I can't get my based 10 percent GDP growth at the peak of the oil crisis! or my restoration of the pre-war order in full! worst of all, I can't build my big bad battleship fleet to destroy kriegsmarine! GIVE ME MY JELLYCOE BACK! give me my DAVID STERLING MSA SOLDIERS OF THE QUEEN BACK!!!
​
https://redd.it/18cz1ve
@tnomod
Reddit
From the TNOmod community on Reddit
Explore this post and more from the TNOmod community
You live in the TNO world, and an alternate history mod has been released for HOI4, in which Germany lost WW2. How will you react?
https://redd.it/18eu049
@tnomod
https://redd.it/18eu049
@tnomod