◼️Fatima is Fatima

▪️Author: #Dr_Ali_Shariati

#Part_6

🔰I do not know what to say about her or how to say it?

♦️I wanted to imitate the French writer who was speaking one day in a conference about the Virgin #Mary. He said, "For 1700 years all of the speakers have spoken of Mary. For 1700 years, all philosophers and thinkers of various nations of the East and West have spoken of the value of Mary. For 1700 years, the poets of the world have spent all of their creative efforts and power in their praise of Mary. For 1700 years, all of the painters and artists have created wonderful works of art showing the face and form of Mary.
🔻But the totality of all that has been said and the efforts of all the artists and thinkers throughout these many centuries have not been able to better describe the greatness of Mary than the simple words, 'Mary was the mother of Jesus Christ.'
And I wanted to begin in this manner with #Fatima. I got stuck. I wished to say, 'Fatima was the #daughter_of_the_great_Khadija,' but I sensed this would not fully describe Fatima.
I wished to say, 'Fatima was the #daughter_of_Muhammad,' but I sensed this would not fully describe Fatima.
I wished to say,'Fatima was the #wife_of_Ali,' but I sensed this would not fully describe Fatima.
I wished to say,'Fatima was the #mother_of_Hassan_and_Husayn,' but I sensed this would not fully describe Fatima.
I wished to say, 'Fatima is the #mother_of_Zaynab,' but I still sensed this would not fully describe Fatima.
🔺No, these are all true, and none of them is Fatima, #Fatima_is_Fatima.

🔘🔜

@rahyafte_en

#Quran (3:59)
#Mubahalah

#Jesus #Mary #truth

@rahyafte_en

🔍 The Virgin Mary is NOT Aaron's Sister! - https://jscenter.ir/judaism-and-islam/israiliyyat/15413
A Response to a Common Misconception About Quran 19:28

📖 Quranic Verse in Question:
"O sister of Aaron! Your father was not a wicked man, nor was your mother unchaste!" (Quran 19:28)

---

❓ The Alleged "Error"
Some critics claim the Quran mistakenly confuses Maryam (Mary), mother of Jesus (AS), with Miriam, the sister of Moses and Aaron (AS), who lived centuries earlier.

Their Argument:
- The Torah mentions Miriam (میریام) as Moses’ sister.
- The Quran calls Mary (مریم) "sister of Aaron."
- Therefore, the Quran "mixed up" two different women!

---

✅ The Clear Response

1️⃣ The Quran Never Calls Mary "Aaron’s Sister"!
- The phrase "O sister of Aaron" is spoken by accusing Jews, not by Allah or the Quran!
- Just as when Pharaoh calls Moses "chief of the magicians" (Quran 20:71), it doesn’t mean the Quran agrees!
- This was a sarcastic remark by Mary’s opponents, mocking her piety.

2️⃣ Why Did They Say This?
- Mary’s mother named her "Maryam" to honor Miriam (Moses’ sister), a revered prophetess in Jewish tradition.
- Mary was raised in the Temple, breaking norms (since Jewish tradition excluded women from priesthood).
- When Mary returned with baby Jesus (AS), her enemies mocked her, saying:
"You claim to be like Miriam (the holy sister of Aaron), yet you have a child out of wedlock?!"

3️⃣ Historical & Linguistic Context
- Miriam (Moses’ sister) was a symbol of purity in Judaism.
- Mary’s naming after her was intentional—her mother vowed her to God’s service (Quran 3:35-36).
- The Jews’ taunt was like saying today:
"Oh, ‘Saint Mary’! How holy you are—yet you have an illegitimate child!"

---

🎯 Key Takeaways
✔ No confusion in the Quran—the critics misread the verse!
✔ The Jews mocked Mary by comparing her to Miriam.
✔ Mary’s name was chosen deliberately to reflect her sacred role.
✔ This verse actually proves the Quran’s deep knowledge of Jewish tradition.

📢 For deeper insights, follow: @rahyafte_en
#Quran #Mary #Islam #Bible #Interfaith

Saint Mary (Persian: مریم مقدس, also Maryam Al-Muqaddasah, Maryam Moghaddas, Maryam Adhraa, and Maryam Al-Muqadasa; "The Honourable/Blessed Saint Mary") is a 2000 Iranian film by director Shahriar Bahrani, depicting the life of Mary, the mother of Jesus, based on the Quran and Islamic tradition.

#jesus #jesuschrist #Mary #maryam #ProphetIesaIbnMaryam

✅ @rahyafte_en