❌ “Perhaps the Prophet ﷺ meant only friendship.”

The proposed document, according to this interpretation, would have removed such ambiguity.

6⃣ 📖 OTHER HADITHS CONCERNING IMAM ALI (ع)

Al-Maliki also stresses that Ghadir is not the only evidence discussed in the Islamic tradition.

He refers to other reports and virtues associated with Imam Ali (ع), including:

🔹 Hadith al-Manzilah — “You are to me as Aaron was to Moses…”

🔹 The Hadith of Brotherhood

🔹 The narration concerning Buraidah

🔹 Other reports concerning Ali’s (ع) exceptional position and virtues.

His argument is that these narrations should not necessarily be examined in isolation.

Rather, their combined meaning and historical context should be considered.

7⃣ ❗ “THE UMMAH FAILED THE TEST”

Perhaps the most provocative conclusion in al-Maliki’s discussion is his assessment of what followed.

According to his interpretation, the Prophet ﷺ made the matter clear, but the Ummah ultimately failed to accept the full implications of that declaration.

Thus, the question becomes much larger than a disagreement between historical personalities.

It becomes a question of:

Who has the final authority when the Messenger of Allah ﷺ speaks?

📌 The Prophet ﷺ — or the political judgment of those around him?

🧩 THE CENTRAL QUESTION

The entire episode can therefore be summarized in one fundamental question:

If the Prophet ﷺ asked for a written document that would prevent the Ummah from going astray, why was that request not fulfilled?

And if the answer is that another person believed his own judgment was sufficient, then:

⚠️ Can a believer place that judgment above the explicit request of the Messenger of Allah ﷺ?

This is precisely the dilemma that Hasan Farhan al-Maliki argues Sunnis must confront honestly.

🔥 THE QUESTION OF GHADIR REMAINS

Was Ghadir merely a declaration of love and friendship toward Imam Ali (ع)?

Or was it part of a broader prophetic effort to establish Ali’s position and leadership after the Messenger of Allah ﷺ?

And was the Calamity of Thursday the final opportunity to put that matter beyond dispute?

These are not merely historical questions. They go to the heart of how the authority of the Prophet ﷺ is understood.

🎬 https://t.me/jscenter/22029

🇮🇷 👉 @jew_media

#HasanFarhanAlMaliki #HadithOfThePen #RaziyyatAlKhamis #Ghadir #GhadirKhumm #ImamAli #AliIbnAbiTalib #AhlulBayt #SunniIslam #Hadith #IslamicHistory

🆔 @rahyafte_en